Account name: Password OpenID? Forgot it?
Remember Me. Technical Difficulties Entries tagged with whitechapel Tags: george chapman , thames torso murders , true crime , unread book challenge , whitechapel View all my reviews.
Tags: true crime , unread book challenge , whitechapel Yours truly, Jack the Ripper Jun. Q1: More about Jack the Ripper! Who do you think did it?
Q3: Are you exclusively reading true crime? If so, what's that been like?
If not, what else are you reading? Tags: ratcliffe highway , road , the river thames , this is for posterity so be honest , whitechapel Tags: san francisco , unread book challenge , whitechapel Timeline, intertwined, of two uncaught Victorian serial killers May. This is for me, as a research tool. But if you're interested, hey, it's also for you. Read more Tags: the angel of the crows , the river thames , whitechapel But Odell is not writing about Jack the Ripper, exactly.
He's writing about the people who write about Jack the Ripper, what they write, and why , and considering the crazy theories that have been put forward in the last century, Odell's wry, generous, thoughtful voice is charming, like a Virgil to lead the reader patiently and clear-headedly through the Inferno of Jack the Ripper Studies, otherwise known as Ripperology.
Odell is himself a major contributor in the field, so he knows the ins and outs of the community of Ripperology very well. He doesn't explain the actual historical crimes and investigations as well as Philip Sugden or Neil R. Bell , and the occasional circumstances of the book's production the Kent State University Press asked him to write about the relationship between American Ripperologists and British Ripperologists for their imaginatively titled "True Crime Series" create an odd, intermittent emphasis on what the Americans happened to be thinking but he's very good at timelines and cross-correlations and using them to poke holes in various whacked-out theories.
His lack of patience for Patricia Cornwell made me very happy. This is an excellent overview of the evolution of the historiography of Jack the Ripper, and a great way to get the gist of books you a most likely can't find and b most likely don't want to have to wade through the elaborate castles-in-the-air accusing the Duke of Clarence, Walter Sickert with or without Sir William Gull , James Maybrick, and a number of other unlikely suspects , but that are important artifacts in the history of this particular and very narrow field of criminology.
Tags: unread book challenge , whitechapel Waddell is a poor writer, showing little regard for his words: e. Such was the euphoria created by the press of the time" He's preachy and prone to platitudes; his prose is clumsy; and he has lamentably zero flair for true crime narrative. I admit he has an uphill battle in trying to write a book about the Black Museum, but still. He perpetuates several myths about Jack the Ripper there were no farthings, polished or otherwise, found near Annie Chapman's body while taking other writers severely to task for perpetuating myths, and I'm afraid I lost a great deal of respect for him when he started defending Sir Robert Anderson's "Mad Jew" story.
I bought this book because the odds of my ever having the chance to visit the Black Museum are very close to zero. And it does provide at least some of what I wanted. But as a book, it was disappointing. Tags: hilldrop crescent , the black museum , unread book challenge , whitechapel He is a sane and responsible Ripperologist--meaning that he assesses evidence logically, refers generally to "the Whitechapel murders" to avoid questions about which women are "canonical" Jack-the-Ripper victims and which aren't, and regards all letters, chalked messages, pieces of kidney, and other communications alleged to be from Jack the Ripper with healthy skepticism--and has done a great deal of research into the lives of ordinary bobbies, specifically in H Division Whitechapel , but more generally in the Metropolitan and City Police.
Questions about uniforms, about training, about what a constable's "beat" actually consisted of, about the likely career path you could rise up steadily through the ranks as long as you didn't trip yourself up by getting sacked for being drunk on duty--which happened a lot , the procedure for interviewing witnesses, communications between Scotland Yard and individual stations, what happened when someone was arrested for drunk and disorderly, where the chinks were for corruption to creep in.
He goes into detail about Sir Charles Warren's rise and fall including some incidents I had never read about before , and throughout he presents the Whitechapel murders as much as possible as they were experienced by the police of London. Hardcover , pages. More Details Original Title. Other Editions 4. Friend Reviews. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
To ask other readers questions about Ripperology , please sign up. Lists with This Book. Community Reviews. Showing Rating details.
More filters. Sort order. Aug 01, Jayson rated it liked it Shelves: format-nonfiction , author-british , pp , subject-jack-the-ripper , genre-historiography , subject-british-history , era-victorian , read-in , subject-books. View all 4 comments. This review with all the links included can also be found here! If you have no prior knowledge on the Ripper murders, do not start here. This book is more of a historical literary analysis of books that have been written about Jack the Ripper and who he is.
Literally, there is about pages of information about the murders. Odell is an established Ripperologist and this is written for those with a serious inter This review with all the links included can also be found here! Odell is an established Ripperologist and this is written for those with a serious interest in the crimes.
Luckily, I have a huge interest and knowledge base about dear old Jack. I was a weird kid. As I said, this book is more of a historical literary analysis, following the trends through the years and Ripperologists. I loved how thorough Odell was. Odell went through it all, combing the evidence that was available to him and all the books that made a mark on history.
For good and for bad, too. He treats it all evenly, which I really like. I read this back in and was impressed by it because it brought in DNA evidence that linked one of the prime suspects to the history.
Aka, he tears it down. While this book is for a very specialized group of people, it was very interesting. You just have to know your stuff already and have read some of the literature.
Unless you want to do a bunch of Googling while reading. Feb 27, Katherine Addison rated it really liked it Shelves: 19th-century , serial-murder , that-great-cesspool , true-crime , whitechapel-london-uk , historiography , jack-the-ripper. I have tried and tried, and I can't think of a better word to describe this book than "charming. Compare similar products.
You are viewing.
About this product Product Information Ripperology - an obsessive interest in studying the crimes of Jack the Ripper - is a subject of interest that has suffered from confusion, exaggeration, and hyperbole. This study presents a sequential history of literary investigations of Jack the Ripper's crimes, and aims to tell the story of the literary efforts directed at solving the mystery.
Additional Product Features Author s. Robin Odell has written or cowritten fifteen books in the fields of criminology and forensic science. Show more Show less. Ratings and reviews Write a review. Most relevant reviews. Best-selling in Non Fiction See all. Kiyosaki Paperback,